CarInsuranceGuide Updated May 2026
CAR INSURANCE COMPARISON 2026

State Farm vs Progressive

State Farm vs Progressive compared for 2026. Progressive is $1,130/year cheaper on average. State Farm wins on customer service and agent support.

Our Verdict
Progressive Wins on Price — State Farm Wins on Service

Progressive is $1,130/year cheaper for the average driver. But State Farm's A++ rating, largest agent network, and top claims satisfaction make it worth the premium for many drivers.

State Farm
Avg Full Coverage/yr~$3,189
AM Best RatingA++ Superior
Market Share#1 (18.64%)
Telematics ProgramDrive Safe & Save (30%)
Best ForService, bundling
Get State Farm Quote →
Progressive
Avg Full Coverage/yr~$2,059
AM Best RatingA+ Superior
Market Share#2
Telematics ProgramSnapshot (up to 30%)
Best ForPrice, high-risk drivers
Get Progressive Quote →

Price Difference at a Glance

State Farm
$3,189/yr
Annual Savings with Progressive
$1,130/yr
Progressive
$2,059/yr

Based on national averages for a good-driver profile with full coverage. Your rate will vary by state, age, vehicle, and driving history.

Frequently Asked Questions

Progressive is significantly cheaper — $2,059/year vs State Farm's $3,189/year, a difference of $1,130/year. That said, rates are highly personal. Drivers with a clean record may find GEICO beats both. Progressive's advantage grows after accidents or violations.
State Farm wins by a wide margin. It has the largest agent network in the US, top J.D. Power satisfaction scores, and an A++ financial strength rating. Progressive scores below average for claims satisfaction. If service matters most, pay for State Farm.
Progressive. Average car insurance rates increase 88% after a DUI — but Progressive is known for more competitive pricing after violations (37% increase vs higher increases from competitors). State Farm may not accept high-risk drivers at all in some states.
State Farm Drive Safe & Save stacks with other discounts for 35-45% total savings — and never increases your rate. Progressive Snapshot saves up to 30% but can increase rates for poor driving habits. State Farm's program is lower-risk for the driver.
Choose State Farm if: you want the best service/agents, you're bundling home and auto, or you're a young driver using Steer Clear. Choose Progressive if: you want the lowest price, you have violations on your record, or you need usage-based insurance flexibility.